Bars

The Thirsty Sportsman

4.6 228 reviews 10:00 AM - 11:00 PM 205 N Armstrong St, Crothersville, IN 47229, United States

Discover this place

Nestled in Crothersville, Indiana, The Thirsty Sportsman embodies the essence of a vibrant local bar. Patrons rave about its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service, making it a favorite among both locals and visitors. The bar features live bands every Saturday and lively karaoke sessions on Fridays, creating a lively backdrop for memorable nights out. Diners have praised the impressive menu, which includes mouthwatering wings, delicious pizzas, and well-crafted burgers. The timely service and affordable prices make it a perfect option for families, as noted by Corey Roberts, who enjoyed both takeout and the welcoming staff. Jeff Dickey highlights that for those within a 300-mile radius, a visit during the 2024 eclipse for cigars and bourbon is a must. A standout review by Fetty Wapp reveals how The Thirsty Sportsman can transform even the most devoted non-bar-goers into regulars, thanks to its eclectic crowd and delightful offerings. Evan Andrew Newton calls it a hidden gem of Southern Indiana, underscoring its exceptional service and impressive beverage selection. Overall, The Thirsty Sportsman is more than just a bar; it’s a community hub where great food, drinks, and an upbeat spirit converge, making it a quintessential stop in the heart of Indiana.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Bar games
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Karaoke
Live music
Live performances
Sports

Popular for

Solo dining

Dining options

Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with The Thirsty Sportsman before visiting.

Reviews for The Thirsty Sportsman

4.6

228 reviews

100%

30%

Review highlights

Based on 228 reviews

The Thirsty Sportsman in Crothersville, Indiana, is widely recognized as a standout bar in the region, praised for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse clientele. Reviewers frequently highlight the lively entertainment options, including live music and karaoke nights, which contribute to an engaging social environment. The food offerings, particularly the wings, pizza, and fries, receive consistent acclaim for both quality and value. Customers also commend the attentive and friendly staff, as well as the bar’s well-curated drink selection, especially bourbon. Overall, the venue is considered a hidden gem in Southern Indiana, appreciated for its combination of great service, vibrant ambiance, and satisfying dining experiences that appeal to both locals and visitors alike.

Jeff Dickey

May 28, 2025

Found this place while looking for a spot that allowed smoking cigars and drinking bourbon during the 2024 eclipse. If you are within 300 miles of Crothersville Indiana, you owe it to yourself to swing by and check it out.

Julia Snyder

May 15, 2025

Karokie every Friday, awesome, and live band every sat, rocking the house down ..and always the best food and service that you can get.....

Corey Roberts

May 11, 2025

We are still fairly new to town and wanted to try something different for dinner. We ordered wings, pizza, and burgers to go. Food was done and ready at the time frame they gave us. The food was on point and hit the spot. The kids loved the pizza!!! Wings were great and there French fries are delicious!!! Bartender was nice and prices were really decent. Will definitely be back for more food and when I’m kid free would love to see what the bar is like!

Fetty Wapp

Apr 07, 2025

Ive never been a "bar" type of gal but this joint made a regular out of me there for a while! All kinds of folks, great music, delish worth the price drinks, staff is A and I've only had pizza but it was great! I recommend 10/10

Evan Andrew Newton

Mar 30, 2025

One of the 'Hidden Gems' of Southern Indiana bars. I should know ; I worked at one for years. Great service, awesome selection, and a very great space, too. Scottsburg should be ashamed of itself. Crothersville has the best bar between here and New Albany. I am a fan! Will be back.

shane hall

Mar 24, 2025

Had a blast there, the band was awesome n the drummer tim Fletcher was really awesome that man really rocks I've been listening to him for more than 32yrs ...

Nikki Booker

Mar 23, 2025

First time here. Bartenders outstanding! Our service is wonderful! Everyone is friendly! I have to give a standing ovation for Whitney the bartender! She made my favorite drink for me! Live music was great. The crowd seem to enjoy them. Pulled pork nachos were amazing!

Paula Majors

Mar 22, 2025

Celebrated my daughter's 30th birthday here! It was great! Great food and drinks, awesome atmosphere just a few friends and family. Really enjoyed it!